The top bats in the 2026-2027 MLB free-agent class

In the 2026-2027 MLB free-agent class, the clear top pitcher is Tarik Skubal, but the same determination does not apply to hitters this year. Unlike previous free-agent classes that featured prominent names such as Aaron Judge, Shohei Ohtani, Juan Soto, and Kyle Tucker, this class offers a group of intriguing candidates vying for the title of top hitter. Here’s an overview of seven hitters and their respective strengths and weaknesses, based on rankings from MLB.com senior national reporter Mark Feinsand.

1. Teruaki Sato, 3B (No. 4 overall)
The case for: Sato emerged as a top Japanese slugger after achieving a Triple Crown in Nippon Professional Baseball with a .306 batting average, 39 homers, and 106 RBIs in the last season. At nearly 28 years old, he may have the highest potential among this selection.
The case against: Sato has not faced MLB pitching yet, raising concerns about how his performance will translate.

2. Seiya Suzuki, RF (No. 5 overall)
The case for: Since signing a five-year deal with the Cubs in 2022, Suzuki has proved to be consistently solid, posting 20-plus homers and an OPS+ of at least 125 every year for the last four seasons. In 2026, he improved his defensive play, achieving a +7 fielding run value.
The case against: He struggles with baserunning and, having turned 32 in August, a decline in his power numbers is a concern.

3. Randy Arozarena, LF (No. 6 overall)
The case for: Arozarena continued his strong performance with another 20-20 season in 2026, joining an elite group of players with such streaks. With a wRC+ of 151, he was among the best at the plate.
The case against: Despite an impressive season, his overall track record has been mixed, and defensive issues raised questions.

4. Brandon Lowe, 2B (No. 7 overall)
The case for: Lowe had a standout 2026 season, hitting 35 homers with an impressive 121 wRC+. His defensive value and consistent performance make him an appealing option.
The case against: As the oldest player on this list, there are concerns about his durability since he has rarely played more than 134 games in a season.

5. Jake Bauers, 1B (No. 11 overall)
The case for: Bauers showed remarkable improvement in 2026, achieving career highs in multiple offensive metrics and earning NLCS MVP honors.
The case against: His career stats indicate a history of underperformance, questioning the sustainability of his breakout.

6. Luis Arraez, 2B (No. 12 overall)
The case for: Known for his contact hitting, Arraez nearly earned a fourth batting title in 2026 and improved defensively, showcasing potential value.
The case against: The significant increase in his WAR raises doubts about whether he can replicate that performance.

7. Jazz Chisholm Jr., 2B (No. 15 overall)
The case for: Despite a tough 2026 season, Chisholm leads all domestic free agents in fWAR since 2024.
The case against: Inconsistent performance during the last season raises concerns about his overall hitting abilities.