Top Fantasy Hockey Picks for First Round based on Scoring

The best first-round fantasy hockey picks based on scoring format were discussed in detail on September 10, 2026, by Shayna Goldman for The Athletic.

A first-round pick does not have to make or break a fantasy team, but it can provide a manager with an elite foundation, putting some pressure on the selection. In terms of keeper leagues, the optimal choice depends on the players available. Regardless of the type of league—keeper or redraft—the league type and scoring impact projected values significantly.

Points Leagues

For points leagues, the scoring system used is: goals (3), assists (3), shots (0.5), blocks (0.5), power-play points (1), shorthanded points (1) and goalie stats include wins (3), shutouts (1), saves (0.5), and goals against (-3).
1. Nathan MacKinnon, C, Colorado Avalanche
MacKinnon is highlighted as a force capable of delivering substantial scoring, shooting frequently, and driving offense. His fantasy value slightly edges out Connor McDavid under these parameters, especially considering Colorado's schedule.
2. Connor McDavid, C, Edmonton Oilers
McDavid, deemed not the wrong choice at No. 1, is projected to score higher than MacKinnon. His power-play performance may tilt the scales if a league values power-play stats more heavily.
3/4. Zach Werenski, D, Columbus Blue Jackets; Cale Makar, D, Colorado Avalanche
Werenski and Makar are closely matched in fantasy value, differing only marginally. The choice may depend on personal preferences or specific league settings.
5. Quinn Hughes, D, Minnesota Wild
Hughes is projected to score higher than Werenski and Makar while contributing effectively to the power play.
6. Evan Bouchard, D, Edmonton Oilers
Bouchard is expected to drive significant offensive contributions from the blueline.
7. Nikita Kucherov, RW, Tampa Bay Lightning
Kucherov remains a consistent scorer, making him a valuable asset for any team.
8. Macklin Celebrini, C, San Jose Sharks
Celebrini offers high potential, especially in keeper leagues.
9. Rasmus Dahlin, D, Buffalo Sabres
Dahlin's all-around play may contribute to the Sabres' improvement.
10. Matthew Schaefer, D, New York Islanders
Schaefer's unique rookie season positions him as a top pick for managers in keeper leagues.
11. Leon Draisaitl, F, Edmonton Oilers
Despite being placed at No. 11, he holds significant appeal for franchise players.
12. Lane Hutson, D, Montreal Canadiens
Hutson represents a valuable option surrounded by other top talent.

In standard category leagues, scoring systems shift, where goals, assists, and various stats weigh equally. MacKinnon and McDavid continue to lead, followed by Cale Makar, who sees increased value given the slightly distinct scoring weight. Overall, strategy pivots around league settings and drafting trends as the draft approaches.